And the winner is…

Liberty's American Bar & Grill

Liberty's American Bar & Grill

51 Route 303
Tappan, NY 10983
Neighborhood: Pearl River area
With 16 flat screens and an extensive selection of drought beers, this is a mecca for sports fans. But add an impressively decorated dining room and an interesting menu, and there's more than enough reason to return after the games are through. There's free wi-fi in the bar, and gratis soda all night for designated drivers.

Nominees

Candlelight Inn

Candlelight Inn

519 Central Ave.
Greenburgh, NY 10583
Neighborhood: Scarsdale area
Forget Atkins. Pub food rules here, meaning chili, oversized burgers, and balboas (hot, sliced roast beef served on a garlic wedge with melted Swiss cheese) reign supreme. Not only is the service friendly, but they also offer mild, hot, extra-hot, and Chernobyl-style chicken wings.
Olde Village Inne

Olde Village Inne

97 Main St.
Nyack, NY 10960
Neighborhood: Nyack-Piermont area
At the OVI, grab some Murphy's stout or one of the other dozen beers on tap and watch some soccer on the TV. They offer Burgers, shepherd's pie, chicken potpie and the like. OVI regulars swear by their wings.
McGillicuddy's

McGillicuddy's

84 Main Street
New Paltz, NY 12561
Neighborhood: New Paltz area
McGillicuddy's is focused on more pub early in the week, and more club on the weekends with DJs and dancing. With a menu that boasts award-winning wings (with more than 20 flavors!), appetizers, burgers, sandwiches and entrees, they are the only late night entertainment venue in New Paltz where the kitchen stays open as long as they do! They offer food and drink until 4 a.m. everyday.
Chumleys BBQ and Catering Company

Chumleys BBQ and Catering Company

56 N. Main Street
Florida, NY 10921
Neighborhood: Goshen area
Chumley's boasts "something different" BBQ ribs, pulled pork and brisket. They have sandwiches, wrap, wings and catering for all occasions.

Last year's winner

Candlelight Inn

Candlelight Inn

519 Central Ave.
Greenburgh, NY 10583
Neighborhood: Scarsdale area
Forget Atkins. Pub food rules here, meaning chili, oversized burgers, and balboas (hot, sliced roast beef served on a garlic wedge with melted Swiss cheese) reign supreme. Not only is the service friendly, but they also offer mild, hot, extra-hot, and Chernobyl-style chicken wings.

Add a comment

Please log in to comment

More on Metromix.com